Act Too PlayersSchool of Music and Theatre

From the directors

How we cast

Every production class auditions in class during week two. These two articles explain how roles are decided and how to help your child when the cast list isn't what they hoped.

The Realities of CastingHandling audition disappointmentCast List

By Sondra Morton · First published February 2016

The Realities of Casting

It's that time again! Casting time! The time when everyone works their butt off to prepare for the audition, come in, give a great audition and then wait for the cast list to be posted. It's a stark realization that with every cast list I post, I have 3 happy students and 20 other students facing disappointment.

Act Too Players is listed as a training school, which primarily means that we don't audition kids to get into a program or a show. If they have the desire to learn, then we have the desire to teach them. Our auditions are for placement within the show, which is something I remind them during auditions! They already get to have the fun of learning a new show!

It is also important for you as the parent to understand and trust our process. Because we are a teaching facility, it is vitally important that we train our students in several different ways. We try very hard to cast your child in the best place, for the best experience. We do our best to mix up the roles, thereby mixing up their experience and learning. A lead role in a show is no more important than an ensemble role. It is important for you to realize this, so that you can help your child realize and understand this as well.

We look for the opportunity to push, challenge, and strengthen your child's ability. This may come in many different forms. We ask that you do not become combative toward the casting process. Looking to other students for inspiration is good; however, making negative comparisons distracts children from focusing on becoming stronger performers.

Casting is hard. Really hard. If you put seven people in the room watching the same auditions, you will end up with seven different cast lists. Casting by its very nature can be very subjective, and it is the reason I often have other auditors in the room with me. (I also record every audition so that I can revisit them over the next couple of days.)

There are a multitude of reasons that casting is so hard. I have found that casting is difficult because we usually have two or three people that could be cast in all the lead roles. I could have two kids up for the lead, and when I decide on one, the other often gets placed in an ensemble role… not because she didn't do well and not because she's not talented. It's the nature of the beast.

I am very clear about one thing. A performer must be able to play multiple types of characters if they want to get work in the real world. Explaining this to young performers, and at times parents, is the challenging part. For some reason, people get it in their head that the lead must be the best performer. Truthfully, it is the strength of the ensemble that makes the leads look so good! As cliché as it sounds, every part really does matter. The lead plays one character; the ensemble member, swing, or understudy must be able to play several. (The quarterback couldn't do his job if the fullback wasn't there!)

Do I like casting? Not really. Do I like watching auditions? Definitely. The thing I enjoy most about watching auditions is seeing the progress in students from semester to semester. I feel proudest when I see a student who wouldn't even open her mouth to say her name in an audition get up in front of the class and sing out for the first time. She may be pitchy. She may be meek. She may not smile. But she sang!

What does Act Too look at when casting?

  • Where will this student be the most successful?
  • How has this student improved since the last semester?
  • What did this student play in the last show, and how can they be challenged?
  • Was this student just a lead? How did they handle that leadership role?
  • If the student was just a lead, how do we challenge them in the ensemble?
  • Is the student about to age out of their age group?
  • Is this student really ready for a lead role and what it means to take that on?
  • What have their leadership skills been like during the current class and past classes?
  • What steps, if any, has the student taken to improve and help encourage others?

I hope this gives you a different insight into the casting process. I always want to make every student happy, and I understand the hurt they feel when the casting isn't what they had hoped. Casting is a necessary evil in the theatre world. If you or your child is struggling with the casting decision, you are welcome to email me to schedule an appointment to review your child's audition (with your child). I want you and your children to feel confident and empowered.


By Sondra Morton and Jayme Smith · First published February 2016

A Parent's Guide on How to Deal with Audition Disappointment

Your young performer has auditioned for a show. They have learned the audition material. They practically sing the audition song in their sleep. In fact, you've probably heard it so much you feel ready to audition for the part. But when the cast list comes out and they aren't cast as the character they had hoped, you find yourself dealing with a multitude of emotions while trying to help your child navigate theirs.

Unfortunately, rejection is a necessary evil of the acting world. Dealing with disappointment and rejection is a lifelong process, whether it's an audition in grade school, not getting an internship, or not getting into your first-pick graduate school.

Do's and don'ts

  • Some parents may compare their child's progress or class placement to another child's. Watch for this behavior in your children as well, and encourage them to focus instead on their own accomplishments.
  • Allow your child to feel upset and disappointed. Encourage them to express their feelings.
  • Focus on the positive! Remind your child how much they have improved since beginning, or how well they felt after the audition.
  • Process the disappointment with your child. Let them talk about their experience in the audition, and listen. You might hear them say things like, "I was awful!" or "The other kids were more experienced than me" or "The director didn't like me." In these moments, we recommend a redirect: talk about the things your child can control. Did you feel confident? What would have helped you feel more confident? Did you follow directions? Did you find the instructions difficult to follow? Do you feel like you tried your best?*
  • After you've established the things your child can control in the audition, create a plan to help them improve for the next audition. You really want to encourage your child to try again; rejection is a lifelong challenge, and giving up isn't a good solution. Your plan might include special training, an audition prep workshop, or seeing more shows and discussing the performances. You want to show your child that you take their disappointment seriously and want to help them succeed in the future.*
  • Encourage them to get excited about all there is still to learn! Remind them that the reason they joined the class in the first place was to be part of a show. They are all part of the experience, and every one of them is necessary to a successful show!
  • Music Theatre International (MTI) recommends letting your child brainstorm characteristics for their role. Is she peppy or indifferent? Is he confident or awkward?
  • MTI also recommends encouraging your child to create a back story for their character. Where is the character from? Why is the character in the show? Half the fun is that the audience never has to know the back story, but this exploration will round out the character even more. Have fun, but create a story that works realistically within the director's vision for the show.
  • Remind your child that no two students progress at the same rate, even with the exact same training. Encourage them to focus on themselves, give their all, and be satisfied with their own accomplishments.

We recommend you avoid*

  • Discussing the merits of other people with your child, including other actors or the directing team. You can't control others, so don't waste energy questioning their motives.
  • Over-indulging your child in treats or superficial praise. Listen and validate feelings, but don't inflate skills and abilities to try to make your child feel better. Treats are great on occasion, but avoid using them to make a child feel better; this can create unhealthy habits.
  • Dismissing your child's natural feelings. Phrases like "get over it," "don't be so sensitive" and "you'll live" shut down an opportunity to teach your child healthy emotional processing. Validate the right to feel sad, then create a plan to move past it.

*Recommendations adapted from Treasure Valley Children's Theater. Character-building ideas from Music Theatre International (MTI).

Find a class